HealthETeams Support

  • Chesapeake Bay Area
  • Virginia Beach, VA
  • 23455
  • (757) 636-1775

Collective Impact or Community Action...?

Posted by Thomas Edwards on January 16, 2019 9:50 AM EST
Thomas  Edwards photo

Thanks to the research conducted over the last dozen years or so by Stanford University's social economics group and their publishing of findings of "collective impact" projects in their Stanford Social Innovation Review (SSIR) periodicals.....

...there is increasing knowledge of the concept of "collective impact".  And their reporting has added clarity to the key success elements to the concept that can be applied to community-wide social economic projects of all types and sizes.

And "hats off" to Joe for raising the idea in his last blog post that attacking the substance abuse issue and the opioid crisis with a collective impact model is an important and practical idea.  His notion that perhaps a community-wide project that would be kicked off with a summit or information sharing and connection event (SUD Summit) as an additional element to the research on the collective impact concept is both novel and relevant.

As I read through his blog post, it occurred to me that perhaps calling the concept a "community action" project may be a good way to not have it lost in the bigger ideas of "collective impact". By this I mean to suggest that using the "collective impact" model and enhancing its name slightly to include other elements of how the model can be applied for a specific social economic issue which may be nationwide but dealt with on a regional basis may help it stand apart from academia and have a clear bias to action.  In other words, such a project name suggests it is based on an evidence-based approach-"collective impact".  But it also acknowledges that there may be differences in terms of how that model could be executed in a given region.

Clearly, any such project must have as its ultimate goal to achieve measurable improvements in the issue being targeted.  So, the word "impact" is a powerful way to convey that focus.  And the descriptor of the word "collective" identifies the need for disparate groups to collaborate for the greater good of a particular project or set of projects.  

I propose we consider a term such as "community Action" project as a way to leverage the concept of collective impact with a bias for taking action.  Perhaps the actions taken will be small at first, but measurable and meaningful in terms of the community's learning and sense of progress.  My notion here is that by boiling the focus to actions that can be taken to achieve the long term objective of sustained collective impact, makes it easier to get started versus spending much time and energy discussing the perfect solution and not taking action at all.

We know from our reading and writing around the concepts of innovation that getting started with a "good enough" initial effort enables bold change to happen in a positive, measurable, expandable and sustainable way.  Thus, while the proven model of "collective impact" gives us a foundation to build on, the "community action" focus or naming convention gives us a shorter term way to begin to take steps forward without over-thinking (and over shooting) the goal of community-wide improvements on social economic issues whose resolutions matter greatly.

In essence, the idea is to apply the principles of disruptive innovation to the concept of collective impact and applying it right at the issue of community-wide improvements and reduction in substance use disorder (SUD) by focusing on SUD recovery and the key actions that can be implemented at scale in local regions and communities.

There are no comments

Sign in to add your comment.

Recent Posts

Medicare Expansion in Democratic Candidate Debates Misses Point
Interesting "Other Views" op-ed piece by the former publisher of The Daily Press casts a...
read more
The Five Essential Elements of Well Being: Revisiting Gallup Research Findings
In their outstanding 2010 book, renowned researchers and authors Tom Rath and Jim Harter laid out...
read more
What is a "SPECK"?
Emerging interest and growth for new ways to engage the right people, in the right way for the right...
read more
"Hybrid" Population Health Management Model May Work
Traditional command and control techniques can drive immediate change in healthy lifestyle...
read more
Innovations in Population Health Management Could Benefit from Command and Control Techniques
Chip's recent blog post (July 5th) espousing the reluctance of some managers and leaders to inspire...
read more
Management Innovations Must Include More Openness and "Freedom"
Yesterday, we Americans once again celebrated the precious freedoms that were provided in the...
read more
Why "Supply Side" Solutions to the American Healthcare Crisis Aren't Working
A recent article in Inside Business, Hampton Roads' weekly business news tabloid, and a chat with...
read more
The Magic Of Baseball: The Social Wellness Power of Teamwork at Its Best
The benefits of sports in general, and baseball during the summer, are enormous. Teaching skills,...
read more
Employers Are Turning to Workers to Monitor Peers To Prevent Shootings
The tragedy in Virginia Beach has spurred bold thinking from many in the crime prevention field....
read more
The Strategic Importance of "Why?"
A couple of friends, and a business consultant have separately recommended to me to read two...
read more

Go to blog